Proximity, Recency, Frequency, Similarity, Publicity: A Plain-English Guide to the Timberwalk Factors That Decide Whether a Texas Attack Was Foreseeable

Texas judges weigh five factors about earlier crimes to decide if an owner should have expected an attack. How each one works and the records that prove it.

Proximity, Recency, Frequency, Similarity, Publicity: A Plain-English Guide to the Timberwalk Factors That Decide Whether a Texas Attack Was Foreseeable

Ask a Texas lawyer who handles security cases what the first big battle usually is, and the answer is often the same word: foreseeability. To hold an owner accountable for a shooting or stabbing it failed to prevent, an injured person typically has to establish that a crime of that kind was something the owner should have seen coming.

Texas does not leave that question to gut instinct. In 1998, the Supreme Court of Texas set out a five-part framework in Timberwalk Apartments, Partners, Inc. v. Cain. Courts across the state still apply it, and understanding each part can help a victim's family see what evidence will matter most.

The case that created the test

Timberwalk involved a tenant who was assaulted inside her apartment. The justices concluded that the record of earlier crime at and around the complex was too thin to make that attack foreseeable, and they ruled for the owner. In doing so, the court explained how judges should evaluate past criminal conduct, and those five considerations are now known simply as the Timberwalk factors.

Factor one: proximity

Where did the earlier crimes take place? Incidents on the property itself carry the most weight. Crimes in the immediate vicinity, such as an adjoining parking lot or the next block, can also count, especially when nothing physically separates the two areas. Events across town usually say little about the danger at a specific address.

Factor two: recency

When did the earlier crimes happen? A cluster of assaults during the preceding months is far more telling than incidents from many years earlier. Courts tend to focus on a reasonable window leading up to the event, though older history may still add context.

Factor three: frequency

How many prior crimes were there? A single isolated event rarely establishes foreseeability on its own. A steady drumbeat of police calls for robberies, fights, or weapons offenses paints a different picture.

Factor four: similarity

Were the earlier crimes like the one that injured the victim? They do not need to be identical. Texas courts generally look for crimes of a type that would alert a reasonable owner to the risk of violence. A history of car burglaries, standing alone, may not predict an armed assault, while repeated robberies or aggravated assaults often will.

Factor five: publicity

Did the owner know, or should it have known, about the earlier crimes? Evidence can include police reports sent to management, tenant complaints, news coverage, emails between staff, and internal incident reports. An owner cannot simply look away; information that was readily available can be treated as known.

How the factors work together

No single factor decides the case. Judges consider them as a whole. A very recent and very similar crime on the property may outweigh a short overall history, while a long list of minor incidents scattered over years may not. The analysis is fact-intensive, which is why gathering complete records early matters.

A second hurdle: unreasonable risk

The Timberwalk factors address foreseeability. In 2017, in UDR Texas Properties, L.P. v. Petrie, the state's high court added an important clarification: a victim must also show the risk was unreasonable, meaning the likelihood and severity of harm outweighed the burden of preventing it. Petrie, who was shot during a robbery in a Houston apartment complex's visitor lot, lost because the record contained no evidence about that burden.

Where the evidence comes from

Building a Timberwalk record usually involves:

  • Calls-for-service and offense data from the responding police department or sheriff
  • Open-records requests for incident reports tied to the address and nearby parcels
  • Management files, resident complaints, and security-company logs obtained in discovery
  • Testimony from a security expert who can connect the history to specific precautions

Some of that information is held by public agencies and can be requested at any time. Video, guard logs, and internal emails, however, are under the owner's control, so a preservation demand should go out promptly.

Time limits and fault

The usual Texas deadline is two years after the incident for injury suits and two years from death for wrongful-death claims. Under proportionate responsibility, a victim whose share of fault exceeds 50 percent cannot recover, and smaller shares reduce the award.

Representation from a practice built on security litigation

Haggard Law Firm lawyers, based in Coral Gables, have spent decades on foreseeability fights in some 500 negligent-security cases, including one that produced $102.7 million from a jury, reported as the U.S. record for this type of claim; the sum is gross. Florida is the only state where Michael A. Haggard is admitted to practice. Each Texas case is handled jointly with a Texas-licensed lawyer, and Mr. Haggard may request pro hac vice admission where court rules permit. Texas counsel stays involved throughout.

Fees are charged only if money is recovered for the client. To request a confidential evaluation at no cost, dial (305) 446-5700 or visit https://crimevictim.attorney/negligent-security/texas/.

Attorney advertising. The legal tests described here are summarized for general understanding and are not advice about any specific claim; reaching out does not establish representation. Mr. Haggard is not a Texas lawyer; his bar membership is Floridian. Results in prior matters are no assurance of how another will end.

Pearl Velmontes
Pearl Velmontes

Hipster-friendly pop culture scholar. General beeraholic. Extreme beer junkie. Typical problem solver. Avid music junkie. Total social media fanatic.